Iconic New York Bakery,
Delivered Nationwide
Handcrafted tradition from NYC's finest bakeries. Black & White Cookies, Rainbow Cookies, Babka and more — shipped fresh to your door.
Iconic New York Bakery,
Free Shipping Over $50
Treat yourself to free shipping when you spend over $50!
Ships in 1-2 Days
Orders ship within 1-2 days for peak freshness
Happiness Guaranteed
Satisfaction guaranteed with every delicious bite of our bakery treats
Knicks Blue & Orange Cookies
For a limited time only, show your love for the NY Knicks with our iconic blue & orange cookies for the playoffs! Make your playoff parties SWEET with our delicious iconic cookies.
Knicks Blue & Orange Cookies
$28.95
Bagel Boss NY Knicks Blue & Orange Cookies
Game day snacks are usually forgettable.
Chips disappear.
Dip gets messy.
Desserts are boring.
So we made something worth showing up for.
Bagel Boss NY Knicks Blue & Orange Cookies — our iconic New York-style cookie finished in bold blue and orange icing.
Same cookie you actually want:
Big, soft, cake-like bite
Half blue icing + half orange icing
Looks game-day ready, tastes like a win
This is what you bring when you want people to go,
“Okay… THAT’S awesome.”
…and then immediately grab another one.
Perfect for:
Game day spreads
Watch parties
Office treats
Party platters that actually get noticed
What you get:
✅ 8 Blue & Orange Mini Cookies per package
✅ Limited-time New York basketball season energy
If you want something festive, iconic, and actually delicious…
Grab the Bagel Boss NY Knicks Blue & Orange Cookies.
Pickup currently not available
Our Signature Classics
Handcrafted with love using time-honored recipes. Every bite tells a story of New York's rich bakery heritage.
Fresh to Your Door
We've perfected the art of shipping New York bakery goods so they arrive fresh, delicious, and ready to enjoy.
Choose Your Treats
Browse our collection of iconic NYC bakery items and build your perfect order
We Pack Fresh
Each item is baked fresh and carefully packed in our custom insulated boxes
Enjoy in 1-2 Days
Your order ships directly to you via overnight or 2-day delivery
New York's Sweet Legacy
Bagel Boss was born from a simple mission: to share these iconic flavors with people across the country who dream of that authentic NYC bakery experience.
Perfect for Any Occasion
Curated collections of our best-loved treats, beautifully packaged and ready to gift.
Get 15% Off Your First Order
Join our list for exclusive offers, new product announcements, and a taste of NYC delivered to your inbox.